Sunday, November 25, 2012

"Lust" Critique


Susan Minot’s short story “Lust” depicts a female, teenage narrator who experiences depression because of the amount of sexual activity in her life. For people with depression, time tends to feel simultaneously drawn out and compacted together. Therefore, to portray this depression, Minot manipulates the story’s time in multiple ways. First, she uses short paragraphs, some only one sentence long, and separates them with an extra space. These breaks function to slow the story down. They also emphasize a jump between thoughts and time within the narrative. Thus, the breaks become a pause in the narrator’s thoughts, as though she is taking a breath as she remembers the convoluted events of her sexual activity.
            Secondly, the thoughts are disordered, the subsequent paragraphs often not relating to one another. For instance, the following sentences are the topic sentences of three successive paragraphs:

            You wait till they come to you.

            The girls sit around in the common room and talk about boys, smoking their heads off.

            I thought the worst thing anyone could call you was a cock-teaser.

The paragraphs that follow each sentence remain on topic, but there is no transition between them. Again, the double spacing is used to indicate a jump in thought, showing that the narrator’s thoughts come at random.
            Finally, the narrator does not mention the boys she has been with in any significant order, suggesting that she does not remember who came when. For example, she first mentions Oliver on page two when she quotes her mother saying, “Oliver seems nice.” Oliver is not mentioned again until page five; however, she talks about eight other boys before returning to Oliver. This shows that she either does not remember or does not care about the order. Thus, time for this narrator has been warped, and Minot manipulates the text’s structure in order to complicate time for the reader.

No comments:

Post a Comment